With hundreds of thousands of pins at Walt Disney World, finding ones that match your personality and interests takes strategy. Here are my top tips for landing the best trades!
1. Start Early in the Day
Morning trades often yield the best results since Cast Members start their shifts with freshly replenished pin collections. This is your prime opportunity to spot rare or unique pins.
2. Visit Resort Merchandise Locations
Some of my favorite trades have happened at Disney resort shops. These locations often have excellent pin boards and fewer traders competing for the best pins.

3. Trade with Leaders
Look for Retail Guest Service Managers (blue ID badges, business casual attire). They typically have fewer guest interactions than regular Cast Members, meaning their pins are traded less frequently.
4. Ask About Trading Boards
Many merchandise shops have dedicated pin trading boards. If the shop isn’t busy, ask the Cast Member if they have a board available. You can take your time examining the options.
5. Connect with Disney Vacation Club Cast Members
DVC Cast Members wear pin lanyards but aren’t on most traders’ radar. This makes them excellent trading partners for finding hidden gems.
Article Continues Below
6. Choose Strategic Locations
Best places to trade:
- Resort gift shops
- Less crowded park locations
- DVC kiosks
- Guest services areas
7. Time Your Trades
Trading success often depends on timing:
- Early morning: Best selection
- Mid-day: Less competition
- Avoid peak shopping hours

8. Check Multiple Boards
Don’t limit yourself to one location. Different pin boards often have different selections, so visit multiple spots during your stay.
9. Build Relationships
Take time to chat with Cast Members while trading. They might share insights about where to find specific pins or when new ones arrive.
10. Think Outside the Parks
Consider trading at:
- Disney Springs locations
- Transportation centers
- Character dining locations
- Special events
Remember: Pin trading is about the experience as much as the collection. Take your time, be courteous, and enjoy the hunt for your perfect pins!

